We keep things moving in these parts with the rest of my forward rankings. I am going to put these guys into tiers with comments on players that I think are worth discussion. For example, I'm not going to talk about Scheifele because at this point, we know he's going to be right around a point per game with his goals coming down to how effective the Winnipeg PP is. For the Top 40, you can read that here. Let's get to it!
I know I haven't covered the forwards outside of the top 20 yet, but with a lot of drafts this weekend, I wanted to get my Top 200 out there as soon as possible. The details on these players are out already (goalies and defensemen) or coming next week (forwards), so this will solely be a list. They will not perfectly align with what I've done so far because some things look different in preseason e.g. Boqvist getting PP1 time. There's also more uncertainty with some contract and injury situations which forced me to move things around a bit. Any questions, comments, or suggestions can be sent in the comments section below. So without further adieu, this year's Top 200!
We're going to move right into the Top 40 defensemen, following the Top 20 defensemen that you can read here. Let's get right into it!
21) Shea Theodore - This tier started with Montour in the top 20 and finishes with Theodore. If I was coaching Vegas, Theodore would be ranked much higher because he would never leave the first power play unit. He's clearly better than Pietrangelo and Hanifin, but to close the season, Hanifin was on the first unit. Theodore is risky because of that, but he's coming off 42 points in 47 games. It's hard to keep him any lower than this.
Today, we're moving up to the blue line. I'm going to cover the top 20 defensemen today, the top 40 later in the week, with the plan of putting out my Top 150 or Top 200 on Friday. I'm on the fence between 150 and 200 just because of how much team needs come into play later in drafts. If I do the Top 150, my plan is to have a separate post early next week about players I'm targeting later in drafts. Anyways, let's get to the kings of the blue line!
We wrap up my goaltending rankings with tiers four and below. Not all 64 goalies that project to be in the NHL will be ranked. For the really bad teams, I will mention their starters but won't mention their backups. I also won't be ranking goalies I have no interest in streaming to start the season, or if the backup goaltending situation is unclear like with Reimer and Levi in Buffalo. If you missed part one, you can check the first three tiers and top 18 goalies here. Let's get to it!
We're through my Top 20 overall and now it's time to focus on specific position groups. I'm starting off with goaltenders and will be breaking them into two tiers. A few things on my general goaltending philosophy for redrafts. If it's a head to head league, I'm never taking a goalie in the first two rounds, and rarely am I taking one in the first four rounds. There is too much variance on a week-to-week basis, and there will be plenty of good streaming opportunities, so there's no reason to invest that draft capital. Sure, it's great to have Igor, but you're going to be too far behind the eight ball offensively. Ideally, I'd end up with two guys in my second tier unless someone at the top falls, and then someone I really like in my third tier. In roto leagues, I'm a bit more willing to take a goalie in rounds 3-4, but again, I'm not going to force it. Unlike the top scorers, almost no goalies are consistent from year-to-year. Last year, five of my top seven goalies were big disappointments, with only Hellebuyck and Shesterkin paying off volume. Oettinger and Sorokin were considered for the #1 overall spot, but neither was a top twelve goalie. Vasilevskiy was injured and then played to horrendous ratios upon return. Georgiev piled up wins but had over a 3 GAA and below a .900 sv%. Saros' numbers dropped as well. Early in the draft, you want certainty, and you're not getting that with goalies. If you followed my rankings last year, I was well above consensus on Talbot, and he finished as the #5 overall goalie despite a dreadful month. There are spots to take advantage of, and hopefully they pan out that way again. Without further adieu, let's look at the cream of the crop!
We're keeping it moving on the hockey side of Razzball with the rest of the Top 20 coming out today. If you missed my Top 10, you can check that out here. Let's get right into it!
11) Jack Hughes - This tier started with Rantanen and finishes with Hughes. Last season was a lost year for the Devils, but I'm fully anticipating a bounce back with better health. Hughes pushed his shot rate to 4.5 per game, which is amongst the league's best. Yes, the PIM and hits are trash, but everything else has a chance to push towards the top of the league. Would you be shocked if Hughes put up 120 points this season like Panarin did last season? Personally, I wouldn't. The upside is so high that I thought Hughes had to go in this tier. There's plenty of superstars in this range, but Hughes is the only one that I could see being a top five player at some point in the future.
It's time! Today, we start our journey through my rankings for this upcoming season. To remind you of how I'll proceed, I start with doing the top 10 and then top 20 players, before moving into specific position groups and an overall Top 200 list. It will take a couple weeks to get everything written up and posted. Let's get to it!
